Heart of Matter: “Preaching a Sky God”

July 2

“If religion is a cosmic and personal phenomenon and God symbolizes the interior depth of consciousness, then how do we still preach and teach a sky God?”

Ilia Delio, The Not-Yet God, Carl Jung, Pierre Teilhard de Chardin and the Relational Whole

2 de julio

“Si la religión es un fenómeno cósmico y personal y Dios simboliza la profundidad interior de la conciencia, entonces ¿cómo es que todavía predicamos y enseñamos a un Dios celeste?”

Ilia Delio, The Not-Yet God, Carl Jung, Pierre Teilhard de Chardin and the Relational Whole

What is being asked?
What is being moved?

View print-friendly version View print-friendly version
Posted in


  1. Maria Aldina Lopes Brás on July 9, 2024 at 4:15 am

    In my humble opinion as a geneticist who believes in God and is not a theologian, I think that the relational myth will be a hope for the future. But, the truth, speaking from a scientific point of view, we have a more
    pragmatic, that culture is the information capable of affecting the behavior of individuals, which they acquire from other individuals through the teaching of knowledge, beliefs, values, and other forms of social learning. There is a co-evolution between culture and human genome. In other words, beliefs are incorporated in our genome.
    Bibliography: Laland KN, Odling-Smee J, Myles S. How culture shaped the human genome: bringing genetics and the human sciences together. Nat Rev Genet. 2010 Feb;11(2):137-48. doi: 10.1038/nrg2734. PMID: 20084.

    It seems more effective to me to change the meaning of ancient myths. For example, the myth of Adam and Eve has been clarified. Scientifically, man derived from another primate.
    Furthermore, if we read Genesis: “12 The man said, It was
    the woman you gave me as a companion gave me fruit from the tree, and I ate.”
    https://www.bibliaon.com/genesis. A clear obedience from man to woman.
    The myth is therefore ridiculed.
    I would greatly appreciate a theologian’s response to my comment. Thanks.

    • Dennis MacDonald on July 11, 2024 at 7:52 am

      Very interesting comment. I think that Joseph Campbell described real ‘myth’ as akin to a cultural skeleton that impacts across cultures, races and time. Though the expressions vary they are roughly identifiable. It seems to me that there are also the cultural ‘stories’ that are adapted and adopted to express valid questions and experiences about life. These are often ‘set’ within a culture based upon the science of the time and the mind-set of the dominant culture or sect. Scientific advances might ‘de-bunk’ their foundation but not their imbedded cultural mind-set. This is particularly true when these primitive ‘answers’ satisfy biases and power structures and have been adopted by a dominant element of a culture as in organized religion and elevated, rationalized and ‘dogmatized’. The Papal Bulls of 1455 & ’93 are examples of how deep and significant ‘constructed myth’ can be. So too, I would suggest, is the exclusion and diminution of women. Joseph Ratzinger’s 2004, “Letter….on the collaboration of men and women in the church and in the world” is a prime example. The ‘domino’ consequences of ‘re-culturization’ are significant. It seems that scientific ‘debunking’ is insufficient, it requires real intellectual integrity and courage. For organized religions it is a real test of real faith.

Leave a Comment


Related Posts

Heart of Matter Fallback Image

Heart of Matter: “The Question Is?”

“The question we have to face, theologically, is this: If divinity is transcendent, personal being, what does this mean in terms of consciousness and the psyche? Is God a shorthand term for…

Heart of Matter Fallback Image

Heart of Matter: “Transcendence of the Psyche”

“God is the name of the Whole of the whole, the transcendence of the psyche. God is within, as archetype, yet more than the collective unconsciousness.” Ilia Delio, The Not-Yet God,…

Heart of Matter Fallback Image

Heart of Matter: “Adapt to the Evolving World”

“Unless religion changes and adapts to the evolving world, it cannot do what it has the capacity to do: enkindle a zest for life.” Ilia Delio, The Not-Yet God: Carl…