Wealth, Power and the Cry of the Earth
Wealth and power are inextricably linked in today’s world. When Donald Trump attended the National Cathedral service in Washington DC, Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde delivered an unexpected message of truth to power. She advocated for vulnerable populations, particularly LGBTQ individuals and undocumented immigrants, urging Trump to show mercy. Bishop Budde’s prophetic words stemmed from her Gospel commitment. Though gentle in delivery, her firm message to America’s most powerful figure seemed to slide off like Teflon. When pressured to apologize, she stood resolute in her convictions. The contrast is stark—had tech titans like Musk or Zuckerberg made similar remarks, it is doubtful Trump would have demanded an apology.
How did we fall into the trap of monetary wealth at the expense of the human person, no less the earth itself? How come human life and creaturely life have so little worth and are as disposable as candy wrappers? The twin forces of wealth and power have always shaped human civilization, intertwined and self-reinforcing. In our modern era, this relationship has become even more pronounced, however, creating a system where financial wealth often overshadows moral authority. The contrast between Bishop Budde’s treatment and that of tech billionaires illustrates this reality. Corporate leaders like Musk, Zuckerberg, and Bezos—whose combined wealth rivals nations’ GDPs—rarely face demands for apologies. Their financial power provides immunity that moral authority no longer commands. This shift extends beyond individual incidents to shape policy, social structures, and our relationship with Earth itself.
The postmodern view that “truth is no longer meaningful” reflects a fundamental shift from belief in objective reality to an emphasis on individual perspectives and power dynamics. In this framework, truth becomes relative and constructed—shaped more by those with power and wealth than by moral or empirical foundations. If you think it is true, then it is true. There is no other norm to assess truth other than one’s own experience. This connects directly to the Bishop Budde incident: her moral truth, though grounded in religious tradition and ethical principles, held less weight than the financial truth wielded by tech billionaires. When truth becomes subjective, wealth and power become the dominant arbiters of what society accepts as true, leading to concerning implications for human dignity, environmental protection, and social justice. The devaluation of objective truth particularly impacts vulnerable populations and environmental concerns, as their realities can be dismissed or reframed by those with financial influence. This explains why corporate leaders face less scrutiny than religious figures challenging power structures—their wealth effectively shapes what society considers true or important.
While Gospel preaching can illuminate moral truths, it rarely disrupts established power structures on its own. Financial and political systems remain largely impervious to purely spiritual challenges, requiring broader systemic action for meaningful change. Bishop Budde’s experience demonstrates this—her moral authority, despite its religious foundation, proved insufficient against entrenched power dynamics. Real transformation demands both prophetic voice and practical reform of wealth-concentrating institutions. But even this type of reform will not be entirely effective unless we ourselves become a different people. The Canadian historian Lynn White noted in his 1967 article on “The Historical Roots of our Ecologic Crisis” that technological and policy reforms alone cannot solve our environmental and social crises. Our fundamental challenges—concentrated wealth and unaccountable power—stem from distorted spiritual values. As White argued, these are religious issues at their core, requiring spiritual rather than merely political or economic solutions. True transformation demands reconnecting with sacred principles about humanity’s role and responsibilities within creation. The root of our problems is religious, he said, and the remedy must be religious as well. We must re-think and re-feel our destiny.
Despite the prophetic stance of the Gospel, our political system has weaponized religion, transforming Christianity into an arena of conflict. The fracture runs deep—from nostalgic Catholic medievalism to Protestant reductionism—reflecting more than denominational divides. We have severed the incarnation from its earthly roots, eviscerating God from the flow of evolution. The incarnation has become “de-carnated” and many Christians have become Gnostic.
Yet a deeper power of reality persists; we remain bound to nature’s laws despite our denial. Every person depends on Earth’s integrity for survival. Yet we continue to treat Earth as mere backdrop for human drama, with science and technology becoming esoteric knowledge for the few. The artificial divide between religion and science lies at the heart of our contemporary moral confusion. We have forgotten our roots as Earth’s children. As Saint Francis of Assisi reminded us, earth is our mother. The ecologically dissociated self has created a world stripped of soul, giving rise to planetary dysfunction on social, moral and political levels. Like any family system under stress, nature will ultimately rebel against this dysfunction. This is what Teilhard realized in 1948 when he wrote:
Mark my word: though (hu)man stands on great stacks of wheat, on mountains of uranium and coal, on oceans of oil, (s)he will cease to develop his unity, and (s)he will perish. If (s)he does not watch over and foster in the first place the source of psychic energy which maintains… the passion for action and knowledge—which means for growing greater and evolving—from which comes unity of mind (p. 173).
Our moral disorientation stems from divorcing religion from nature—like extracting a beating heart from a living body. This crisis extends beyond politics to implicate all who speak in the name of God. Departments of theology are responsible for failing to include nature as the starting point of theology and philosophical reflection; pastors and priests are responsible for delivering outdated homilies born from the ignorance of modern science. The faithful choose comfortable ignorance over scientific engagement. A fractured Christianity is at the heart of a planet in crisis.
While Bishop Budde’s courage merits praise, we confront an evolutionary precipice. Science shows climate change’s role in mass extinctions, yet science also reveals life’s strength through interconnection. Jesus’s question “Who are my sisters and brothers?” points to the profound truth that every creature participates in the emergence of divine love, from stars to wetlands to humanity in all its diversity. True divinity doesn’t intervene from outside but rises up through evolution itself. God needs every single creature to become fully alive. If we push God out of the world, as Nietzsche wrote, then we are left with human hubris. The dangerous fallacy of human self-deification emerges when we forget our place within nature’s web. This hubris—declaring ourselves gods—reflects the very mindset that has led to our ecological crisis and social fragmentation.
We have limited time to integrate science and religion into a new framework of understanding ourselves in this vast cosmos of unfolding life. Without uniting mind, matter, and spirit through conscious evolution, terrestrial life faces catastrophe. Teilhard’s prescient question—“Who will give evolution its own God?”—remains urgent. Until we engage this challenge, we bear Bonaventure’s warning:
Therefore, any person who is not illumined by such great splendor in created things is blind. Anyone who is not awakened by such great outcries is deaf. Anyone who is not led by such effects to give praise to God is mute. Anyone who does not turn to the First Principle as a result of such signs is a fool. Therefore, open your eyes; alert your spiritual ears; unlock your lips, and apply your heart so that in all creatures you may see, hear, praise, love, and adore, magnify, and honor your God lest, the entire world rise up against you. (Bonaventure, Soul’s Journey into God. 1.15)
View print-friendly version
47 Comments
Leave a Comment
Related Posts
The Acceleration of Change: From Future Shock to Present Reality
In 1970, Alvin and Heidi Toffler introduced the concept of “future shock”—a psychological state affecting both individuals and societies, characterized by “too much change in too short a period of…
Father Richard Rohr notes that for many of us, church has taught us about God, but not how to experience and share God’s presence. Without the experience of God’s deep, unconditional love – first shared with us through primary care givers and later fostered through personal and communal prayer and participation in mutual loving relationships – we find false substitutes for that love through the relentless pursuit of wealth, power and control.
For me, trying to stay centered in and sharing God’s love in small ways in my daily life seems especially important in these challenging times. I take comfort in the image of God as loving partner and co-creator that reflection on Teilhard’s teaching has shown me. On many days, it feels as if we’re losing the good fight, that cruelty and indifference are winning out. It takes courage to trust in Love, to trust that God will give us the right response as needed. We need one another to stay that course.
On my walk this morning, I was taken by the beauty of the morning light and was filled with a sense of hope. Afterwards, I wrote the poem below to help me remember and share that moment.
RISE AND SHINE
Sweet morning light spills
Across winter-eyed trees, a-
Wakening to Spring
I’m so grateful to Sr Ilia for continuing the conversations of faith and evolution in the footsteps of Teilhard…
I truly believe in his statement of Love being the true nature of God, and the energy that all matter is composed of (which I call the Holy Spirit flow) is inherent in that Love. Being so, I have hope and faith that it just may be the natural world (Mother earth/creation) and its current resistance to human destruction, that will facilitate necessary relationship between man and the earth, as well as wholeness to mankind of all nations. It’s a global call just as Pope Francis has been preaching since his first encyclical.
Doctrines will fall away as catastrophic events (already happening) will continue to increase awareness of the need to care for and protect our common home, and bring people of all faiths together caring for eachother
All matter continues to evolve and In order to save our species we will have to use science and technology to save our planet, and in doing so care for others. Our time is not God’s time, and God’s mind is not our mind, as I learned in my Catholic grade school, but we are to be his “body” hands,feet,ears,voices… each having our small part and never abandoning the work, both in and out of the church. I say each morning “It’s Your day” asking for guidance along the way. And it’s so wonderful to read the posts of like minded people who move His plan forward towards that Ultimate Love ❤️ Thank you
It appears we are now living in a time of increasing turmoil beyond what we thought could happen again. Thank You for your leadership. You are a prophet.
Offering
The Glory of Truth
We worship in the darkness multiplicity of idols
Receiving the false grace that has no Life
In the wings and ever present is the Light of our forevers
Neglected by the fullness of our pride
And the prophets bring their gifts but we only hear the clamor
So we silence by destruction or neglect
In the wings and ever present is the Light of our forevers
Passed by by empty shells in fancy dress
And we eat the lifeless food and we drink the lifeless wine
We kill to prove that we are still alive
In the wings and ever present is the Light of our forevers
Our appetite to love most nearly lost
The book of days is wearing thin in finite no man’s land
The prideful empty echo sounds there’s no place left to hide
In the wings and ever present is the Light of our forevers
The humble clutched from Death are made alive
June Grifo
Lent 1991
Beautiful and Prophetic 💞
God is a verb… growing, moving, changing healing . Keeping God as a noun/person and Jesus as the only other noun/ person who will ever be fully understand or be one with God condemns humans to tribal subjugation . When will Christianity finally jettison the Nicene Creed, the daily recitation of Iron Age Hebrew war poetry and all mandatory rituals of belonging and finally allow God to flow freely through us … heal us …. evolve us !!
Unfortunately, the Church has been an organized seat of, “financial and political systems” and its mission has been to concentrate wealth and power over truly providing care. Indulgences, greed, fear of the “other” and genocide, have all been, or are, part of the playbook.
The first word uttered by Jesus was repent. Repent as Transform-change your way of being from the inside out. There is no other way to repent. It must be inside out.
Transformation requires reconnecting with our core Divinity and thereby remembering our connection to this sacred Earth and to all matter. That is our “role and responsibility” within creation.
The ” severing of the incarnation” is centuries old and began with the Great Schism. Unfortunately it is still the default religious teaching of today. Unfortunately, this way of being brings a desire to “know God”, in a theoretical way, rather than learning the experience of living WITH God in an experiential way. Living with God as an experience is to live with God in the womb of our Mother Earth!
Nature has God within. Pantheism. No, God is not the tree but the tree has a divine core called Christ. Christ IS the fundamental strands of each and every piece of matter. God is found within our relationship with that matter.
That’s why the Celtic Christians call nature the Big Book and Scripture the Little Book
Love this
“We”, i.e., humanity is not ready, not sufficiently ‘mature’ to leap into evolutionary and even cosmic thinking. Elon Musk leaping into the air in gleeful exuberance at the (Donald J Trump) promise of ‘going to Mars’ seems a suitable metaphor. Keep teaching, describing, encouraging but with the restraint of a parent who is raising an ADHD adolescent child: excessively compulsive, irresponsible and devoid of the maturity of interdependence, responsibility, mutuality, empathy or compassion. It is reminiscent of the original colonialism and racism that was fomented by 15th century greed and Papal (Doctrine of Discovery) rationalization and encouragement. I think that it was Archimedes who said: “Give me a place to stand and a lever and I would move the world”. Now that’s ‘cosmic thinking’. However, even if we had ‘the lever’ we don’t have a ‘stable’ place to stand that would prevent us from ‘moving the earth’ to destruction.
Unfortunately,, I don’t have the same feeling about Archimedes or Elon Musk. I fear Archimedes and his “lever” was “into” control and would be more aligned with the power grab of Musk and Trump.
It’s interesting to watch the dynamics of those two… despite the “power of the presidency” the ” ultimate dollar” seems to trump Trump.
President Trump said Thursday, February 6, 2025, that his relationship with religion had “changed” after a pair of failed assassination attempts last year, as he advocated at the National Prayer Breakfast at the Capitol for Americans to “bring God back” into their lives.
Perhaps this would be a good time for Ilia’s blog to be presented to him to ponder.
The fact that MT Taranaki Maunga was given legal status as a person by New Zealand, after a long but successful advocacy by the Maori people, should tell you everything you need o know about he present state of Christianity.
It has left out Christ.
Indigenous religions traditionally knew nothing of Christ. Their Gods were those found living with them and caring for them right here on this earth. Most Indigenous religions have\had a Supreme God, A Creator Spirit who was over all and guiding. No simple religion. Quite a complex pantheon requiring deep commitment and prayer long before any “organized” religion came to “civilize”.
There were no tithes, no pews were needed but worship and praise sang from every mountain, stream, village, and person.
Perhaps we need the courage to rethink the need to refrain from such “pagan” ways.
I know the despair caused by the apparent advances of evil in the world. That is part of the intent of the perpetrators of evil: to tamp us down with oppressive discouragement. But, while it is urgent to speak Truth to power and to act in resistance, we must keep reminding ourselves that we are co-creators in and with Christ. Every day must include communion with God to receive the energy which sustains the Light in us. We acknowledge our limits and the wonderful Unknown, watching for the Strength made complete in our weakness. From that standpoint we create the word and deed for which we are created and trust that they will be combined with all the word/deeds of the rest of us to move ahead in God’s Will.
So very true… Our God has a plan and we are a part of it 🙏♥️